Tuesday, January 19, 2010

This took a lot of time. Not so much with the Photoshop or even with the write-ups, but with finding episode-specific pictures and videos on YouTube, for which I was almost entirely successful (one I couldn't embed, which kind of threw off my overall plan, but it's no big). Here goes!

Favorite Episodes of Television 2009

10. Modern Family - “Run For Your Wife”



I started watching this show because Eric Stonestreet, who plays Cameron, went to my high school, although he graduated six years before I showed up. But it’s a great sitcom all around - I’ve enjoyed it more than Glee (blasphemy!). Funny, entertaining and with characters that - and this is sometimes rare in TV - I actually like. The show was funny before this sixth episode, but this to me felt like when everything really clicked into gear.



9. Star Trek - “Balance of Terror”



In which we first meet the Romulans. The original series is often can be campy, but this episode is deadly serious and tense; I read a review that likened it to a Cold War submarine movie, which is dead-on. Everyone - the actors, the writer, the director - brought their A-game.



8. Deadwood - “Sold Under Sin”



I feel like the appropriate level of praise I could bestow upon Deadwood would be taken as hyperbole, but it’s a fact that the level of quality in every aspect of the show is unlike most else in TV.



7. Big Love - “Come, Ye Saints”



The very large Henrickson family takes a cross-country trip, visiting the most important locations in the history of the Mormon religion as they do so. As one often sees in film, traveling lends an opportunity to strip characters down and allows them self-reflection in a way that can be difficult when trammeled in by their day-to-day lives. A beautiful, heart-breaking episode.



6. Fringe - “Bound”



I didn’t catch Fringe when it started. Then Alyssa wrote an incredibly scathing review of the second episode (scroll down to September 17) and I figured I’d not waste my time. Then, about three months ago, I saw this gif somewhere:



And I was like, I absolutely have to watch this show. So I checked it out from the library, and…this is one of those things where Alyssa and I will just have to disagree, because I love this show. No, the science isn’t real and it doesn’t make any sense, but I love the floating location tags, I love the characters and the actors who play them, I love the mood and the music and the funny. I picked this episode not just because it’s around when the show really started finding its feet - as well as defining its internal mythology - in season one, but also because of what came before it. The episode before ended in a cliffhanger as FBI agent Olivia Dunham was abducted. A lot of shows would have had that female character in peril all hour, finally to be rescued by a man. This show? Olivia rescued her own damn self before the opening credits. Awesome.



5. Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles - “Self Made Man”



Cameron is a Terminator assigned to protect John Connor. Terminators don’t sleep. So what does Cameron do every night? That’s the premise of this episode. What I loved about this show was how well it was able to expand from its basic premise, which we all know from the films, to create its own intricate and unique universe. While there were a lot of pure killing machines on the show, Cameron wasn’t the only Terminator to be a character in her own right, and watching her investigate with the dogged determination only a computer mind can bring to bear while being forced to interact with illogical humans made her one of my all-time favorite characters.



4. Dollhouse - “Belonging”



There are a lot of Whedon fans who seem to grudgingly watch this show, out of loyalty it seems, who don’t seem to actually enjoy it. It’s pretty common, when reading message boards or blogs about it, to see more complaints than anything else. Which I don’t get. It started off a little wobbly but don’t most shows? I’m very sad it’s been canceled, especially since the second season has brought us stellar episodes like this one, exploring the ramifications of the Dollhouse and how the dolls ended up there in the first place. Visually, this is one of the most stunning thus far. NB: This episode was directed by Jonathan Frakes.



3. Father Ted - “The Passion of Saint Tibulus”



Bishop Brennan asks Father Ted and Father Dougal, priests who have essentially been exiled because of their incompetence to tiny and remote Craggy Island off the coast of Ireland, to boycott a film that the Church has condemned. A film that no one on the island was planning on watching until the Fathers handcuffed themselves in front of the theater with ridiculous signs. I had to pause this episode three times because I was laughing too hard to live.

Video here - I couldn’t find one with embedding enabled. :(

2. Star Trek: The Next Generation - “Cause and Effect”



It’s a fairly straightforward SF premise, really: the Enterprise gets stuck in a time loop that keeps repeating itself, and must figure out how to get out and save the ship. The structure of the episode could have made it even more boring: each act repeats itself, with slight changes as the crew figures out what’s going on, but the basic action is the same. It’s also a bottle episode, so no big battles or special effects. It ends up being so fantastically fabulous that I have to give a lot of the credit to the director: that’s right, Jonathan Frakes! When you’ve got two episodes in my top ten, you’re doing something right.

I also should point out that I made nine icons from this episode. Nine. That means there was some prime Beverly Crusher action going on in here, and you know how I feel about that.



1. Battlestar Galactica - “The Oath” / “Blood on the Scales”



Okay, two episodes, but how could I really pick one? I’m not sure what I need to say about this two-parter. Action, tension, romance, lots of killing and running and even crawling the length of the ship. Roslin and Balter stuck somewhere together, bitching at each other. Starbuck holding her guns in a stupid, improbable way yet still being badass. The music when everyone joins Adama in the corridor. “I am coming for all of you!” Perfection.

9 comments:

Caroline said...

I love Modern Family. I feel like the characters are very believable; they seem to have a history and a life beyond what we see on the screen. I feel like they could make Gloria's and God, I can't remember her husband's name at the moment, but their relationship very cliched, but it's not. I have a lot of affection for Glee and probably personally enjoy it more, but Modern Family is a cleaner show to me objectively.

Shannon said...

I think you articulated perfectly why I enjoy the show so much: they really do feel like real people, and not just bundles of "funny things" to bounce jokes off of.

Haha, you mean you couldn't remember Gloria's nasal "JaaaAAAAyyyyYYYY..."? I can never remember the middle daughter's name, actually, though, so I can't throw stones.

Caro said...

Even when its not a super hilarious episode of Modern Family, I still really enjoy it because I like the characters, which says a lot, I think.

The one thing that can bug me is the documentary framing device. I get that it's not supposed to be literal, and it leads to some funny asides, but it can be distracting.

Shannon said...

Actually, I rarely even think about the doc format; that seems to be how a lot of sitcoms are shot anymore. I find it a lot less invasive than laugh tracks, at any rate.

Holly said...

So,
a)Squee.
b)Beverly's pretty good at squeeing, herself, I see.
c)I have *got* to get in on some of this Father Ted action once I'm done with Battlestar -- it really looks like my kinda show. Also, the dancing scientist gif fills me with joy; I may have to check that out, too.

Shannon said...

Are you a one-show-at-a-time kind of person, then, Holly?

I'll have to find some of my other favorite Walter moments from Fringe. Some of it's scripted, some is clearly just John Noble being brilliant and amazing.

Holly said...

I seem to be -- not a lot of time, and not a lot of ability to spread my focus around, I think. I haven't touched TNG since I've started Battlestar.

Alyssa said...

I have only recently even heard of Modern Family. I should probably catch up on that.

I still threaten to end people with my eye teeth in regular, everyday conversation. Even though I can honestly say that I've come down on the side of disliking 75% of what BSG did with 4.5, Blood on the Scales/The Oath would probably be my pick for the best episode of 2009 TV, too.

Shannon said...

I had had more problems with 4.5, too, but I think now the only episode I just don't understand and don't like would be the one with Liam (I don't want to spoil Holly - you know which one I'm talking about?) because that whole thing was kind of nonsensical and really retconny. But Islanded and Someone to Watch Over Me grew on me after repeat viewings. I think my major problems - aside from the Liam episode - were more in editing and the like than they were in the actual stories (Adama's endless bawwww, for example).

I find that I have a lot more problems with the back half of S3, actually. But BSG was never good with pacing season arcs, unfortunately.

Modern Family's really funny. You could def just catch an episode on Hulu and see if you like it; it's not really necessary to know all the backstory and such.